In Brief
Centre told SC that excluding affluent SC/ST members via 'creamy layer' is Parliament's prerogative, not court's domain — reservation policy is constitutional matter.
On August 7, 2026, the Government of India filed its response in the Supreme Court case regarding application of 'creamy layer' criterion to scheduled caste (SC) and scheduled tribe (ST) reservation beneficiaries. The government argued that decisions on modifying reservation scope fall entirely within Parliament's legislative domain and courts should 'refrain from directing the executive to frame policies.' This is a significant statement on separation of powers in reservation policy.
The case questions whether affluent members of SC/ST communities should be excluded from reservation benefits — a principle currently applied to Other Backward Classes (OBCs) via the creamy layer concept. The government's stand is that Article 46 and reservation provisions of the Constitution are matters of policy determination for elected representatives, not judicial intervention. It cited previous SC judgments supporting parliamentary supremacy in reservation matters. This creates direct constitutional tension between judicial review and parliamentary sovereignty.
Background: Creamy layer concept was first applied to OBC reservations in 1993 (Indra Sawhney case). Some petitioners argue SC/ST communities should have similar economic criteria to prevent wealthy members from accessing benefits meant for disadvantaged sections. Government contends SC/ST communities are socially disadvantaged regardless of income — hence creamy layer doesn't apply. This distinguishes constitutional basis of SC/ST vs OBC reservations.
Exam importance: This is HIGH-level Constitutional Law testing understanding of Articles 15, 16, 46; creamy layer doctrine; constitutional vs policy matters; and separation of powers. UPSC Mains certain topic: 'Discuss the applicability of creamy layer to SC/ST reservations — constitutional and social perspectives.' Marks distinction between Constitutional provisions and policy implementation — critical for IAS interviews and ethics papers on social justice.
SC allows lighting of lamp at Deepathoon as one-time measure
21 Nov 2026
'Bike taxis safer for young girls': Supreme Court allows ops to continue in Karnataka
21 Nov 2026
CBSE moves Supreme Court to recall Class 6 exemption from three-language policy
20 Nov 2026
Justice Yashwant Varma says resignation not admission of wrongdoing
20 Nov 2026